In the final scene of the movie, george vi, facing the dreaded microphone, reads his speech. The true story behind the netflix movie the king time. Sederer, md the king s speech, starring colin firth and geoffrey rush, and directed by tom hooper 2010, is a story of courage amidst disability. However, as contentions surface about the films historical accuracy lionel. In a critically and commercially disappointing year for the film industry, one of the few highlights has been the reception given to the king s. Aug 23, 2017 by movie standards, the film was pretty accurate. Avenue garden, regents park, london nw1 after the cathartic session during which the future king unleashes a torrent of language rarely used by royals in public, bertie and his therapist take a relaxing walk in the park. Hugo vickers, royal adviser on the film the king s speech my view is that a film is a film, and you have to move the drama on. The film tells the story of king george vi colin firth and his battle with a speech impediment.
The kings speech is an ugly distortion of history the new republic. The king is a rather serious adaptation, without much humor or levity. It does show the modern viewer the importance of the treatment given to the king for his speech impediment. The kings speech is an extremely wellmade film with a seductive human interest plot, very prettily calculated to appeal to the smarter filmgoer and the latent anglophile. The movie has been nominated for just about every existing award, and a bevy of oscar nominations are forthcoming. The patriot the movie, the patriot, is the story of a south carolina plantation owner, benjamin martin, who leads a local militia against british troops in the south during the beginning of the.
So thank heavens for the the king s speech, says keith austin, who, like george vi. From these selections, the most inaccurate movie is the imitation game with just a 35. It was an unlikely box office champion because it was based on a true story about the relationship between king george vi of britain 18951952 and an. In this film, colin firth plays king george vi and the events that. History extras anne curry notes that henry the prince was a far cry from henry the king. Aug 25, 2011 the king s speech tells the story of the man who would become king george vi, the father of the current queen, elizabeth ii. Author peter conradi says the relationship between king george vi. There is a reason that this movie, starring colin firth and geoffrey rush, received four oscar awards and was nominated for another eight 1. As i look into the historical accuracyor lack of historical accuracyin this film, i run across article after article crying foul.
Jan 09, 2011 how historically accurate is the king s speech. Its based on the true story of george vi, the father of the present queen of england. Not shown but later referenced in the film is the fact that in the crowd was lionel logue geoffrey rush, a speech therapist recently transplanted. Like many entertainments of this pophistorical type, the kings speech wears history lightly no matter how heavy the crown. The king s speech david seidler screenplay by seesaw filmsbedlam productions.
The premise behind the king s speech is a rather dry one and the trailers themselves make it seem to be a cross between the madness of king george and pygmalion, but thanks to some winning. Feb, 2011 there are many other instances of artistic license in the kings speech. The kings speech perpetrates a gross falsification of history, hitchens. The kings speech is about prince albert who later became george vii he was not expecting to be king he was second in line to the throne but his brother abdicated the throne in order to marry an american divorcee that he had continue reading home. For example, bertie chose his regal cognomen, george, out of respect for his father and not as the film has it. Despite massive commercial success the film is guilty of altering events to better fit the dramatic storyline. Well find out how compelling when the academy awards are announced feb. The movie shows that his speech impediment was a result of his insecurity and shyness. With colin firth, geoffrey rush, helena bonham carter, derek jacobi. The kings speech is mesmerising, moving and beautifully judged, and cinematically it is right up there with dame judi denchs mrs brown and dame helen mirrens oscarwinning the queen. Jan 06, 2011 the kings speech is an ugly distortion of history. Now this historical event has become the subject of the awardwinning film, the kings speech tks, which provides a sympathetic and accurate portrayal of stuttering since the kings speech movie was released, have you noticed an increase in speech language therapy requests.
So thank heavens for the the king s speech, says keith austin, who, like george vi, learned to overcome this common but terrifying. It is based on the life of oliver cromwell, who rose to lead the parliamentary forces during the later parts of the english civil war and, as lord protector, ruled great britain and ireland in the 1650s. The kings speech gives the impression that george vi and his speech therapist worked together for only a few years in the mid1930s, when in reality the two began their relationship as early as 1926. A beautifully crafted historical drama, it explores a side of british history not often discussed by americans. The kings speech is a 2010 historical drama film directed by tom hooper and written by david. If youre looking for a history lesson, keep in mind there are some facts the king got right and wrong. Join us as we examine 2015s oscarwinning movie the kings speech, starring colin firth as the reluctant king george vi and geoffrey rush as his unconventional speech therapist lionel logue, an australian with no formal qualifications but with a history of great success in the field of speech therapy. There has been some debate about the historical accuracy of david seidlers script in which the quirky australian speech therapist, lionel logue. An impressive part of the film was the way it accurately depicted the important relationship between the mechanical and psychological aspects of speech and stuttering. Jul 17, 2014 it seems as though historical films never get all of the details right about the actual events. With colin firth playing a royal with a stutter, the king s speech is certain for oscar magic, but andrew roberts says it gets the story all wrong and. Of course, when the king made his famous speech after chamberlain had declared war on germany, none of those highranking officials who. Colin firth makes an excellent king george vi so excellent, in fact, that he earned himself an oscar nomination for best actor. I took the opportunity to see this movie in theaters when it first came out, in 2010.
Think the blazing joys of chariots of fire where the race is to the end of a sentence. King george v delivers the first royal christmas message over the radio and bullies his son albert, the duke york. The kings speech is an ugly distortion of history the. How historically accurate was the kings speech 2010 movie. Sometimes, these creative choices can be beneficial. The king s speech is a feel good movie, but a very adult one, and while it tells a good story, well scripted, absorbing and believable except for an odd line or two, tom hooper s film is far more driven by character than by plot.
The king s speech is a warm, wise film the best period movie of the year and one of the year s best movies, period. Cromwell is a british 1970 historical drama film written and directed by ken hughes. At long last, a positive portrayal of stuttering the. As christopher hitchens points out in slate, winston churchill was a close friend and supporter of nazisympathizer king edward viii george vis brother, who abdicated the throne in order. With many of the events added for entertainment value it is still a wonderfully british drama, which touches on themes of friendship, love and overcoming the odds. With 12 oscar nominations, the kings speech is among the most nominated films of all time. People can say, for example, that churchill didnt play nearly as big a role as he does in the film he wasnt actually there at such and such a point, he never uttered those words, and so on. The kings speech is a 2010 historical drama film directed by tom hooper and written by david seidler. The true story of netflixs the king, henry v history. As fans anticipate the season 6 premiere of the series, that is one of many questions still sparking. This movie also captures the real sense of anxiety in britain in the 1930s and it broadly captures the historical context of the coronation of george vi.
The salacious antics detailed in shakespeares verses may be dramatized, the historian explains. So thank heavens for the the king s speech, says keith austin, who, like george vi, learned to. Did a latenight meeting result in churchill and king george vi becoming friends. A sickly youth, he had been happy to languish in the shadow of his older, mo. For this list, were taking a look at the historical accuracy behind this netflix drama. Dec 18, 2010 the king s speech delivers solid drama with a rousing climax a fully satisfying and uplifting period piece that achieves its dramatic potential without sacrificing historical accuracy. But does this historical drama starring timothee chalamet and robert pattinson do justice to history. Anyone whos been following modern cinema has probably heard of the king s speech currently the frontrunner for best picture at the upcoming academy awards. In that sense, the movie accurately portrayed the myriad of techniques available at the time, especially for an untrained speech pathologist such as logue. The kings speech is being sold as a feelgood tale of how a. As a specialist in british history, i agree that screenwriter david seidler certainly has tweaked the record a bit and telescoped events in the kings speech but for the same artistic. The buzzy new movie, the kings speech, is an affectionate portrait of queen elizabeth iis parents, bertie, the duke of york later king george vi and elizabeth the duchess of york later the. If he did have the disease, it was likely mild or at least hadnt affected. How historically accurate is netflixs new shakespearean drama.
British pathe is a treasure trove of 85,000 films unrivalled in. Outlaw king vs the true story of robert the bruce and his. The kings speech is moving partly because logue is portrayed as being such a master at easing fear. Oct 19, 2015 the kings speech, is based on the incredible trueish story of king george vi, whilst it is not completely historically accurate. What is the historical significance of the kings speech. So while the movie wasnt completely honest, it got out its message. What the film teaches us about life with a disability by lloyd i. The kings speech after watching the movie essay example. In november 2010, worldwide movie audiences were presented with a most interesting and unusual movie release with the king s speech, starring colin firth as king george vi and helena bonham carter as his wife elizabeth. Jan 05, 2011 the story of the stuttering sovereign was not widely known until it inspired the oscarwinning film, the kings speech. Hugo vickers, royal adviser on the film the kings speech my view is that a film is a film, and you have to move the drama on. In a smart, wellmade film would the true story not have been fractionally more interesting for the audience.
The kings speech is an excellent film, but it does take a few pointless liberties with historical accuracy. The speech therapist, lionel logue, started working with king george vi in 1926, not in 1930s. He asks his second son, the duke of york, to give the closing speech at the empire exhibition in wembley, london. Jan 24, 2014 the kings speech shows alberts struggle to overcome his stutter with the help australian speech therapist, lionel logue, against the backdrop of 1920s30s europe, the rise of nazism and predominantly.
The kings speech does show accurately the real problems caused by the future george vi and the entire royal family. It s based on the true story of george vi, the father of the present queen of england. A fully satisfying and uplifting period piece that achieves its dramatic. But it is telling a true story, of how king george vi had a quite crippling stammer that would make a nightmare of all the public appearances involved in being king, and of how t. This was very much the case and george vi did have a very bad stutter from childhood. Please spell me out the cliched and formulaic elements in the kings speech, because even if it is a doubtful academy awards conqueror, tom hooper built a proper historical account about the. Jan 24, 2011 the kings speech is an extremely wellmade film with a seductive human interest plot, very prettily calculated to appeal to the smarter filmgoer and the latent anglophile. Based on the true story of the queen of englands father and his remarkable friendship with maverick australian speech therapist lionel logue. Stuttering and the kings speech stuttering foundation. Author peter conradi says the relationship between king. But the historical sources dont suggest that churchill was on the edge of seeking terms, as is hinted at in. Oct 25, 2019 the true story behind the netflix movie the king. After seeing various speech therapists at no avail, his wife finds a very unconventional speech therapist lionel louge played by geoffrey rush.
Unless you count hitler, who is seen from afar, the narrative. After his brother abdicates, george bertie vi reluctantly assumes the. The kings speech ist eine britische filmbiografie des regisseurs tom hooper aus dem jahre. A sickly youth, he had been happy to languish in the shadow of his older, more virile brother, edward. Essay about historical accuracy of the patriot 950 words. The film starring the ever charming george vi played by colin firth.
What the kings speech teaches us about life with a. Have you ever wondered if the movie you just saw that claimed to be based on a real story or historical events was really accurate. On the heels of its 12 academy award nominations, the kings speech, an inspiring story of king george vi and his triumph over stuttering, is being criticized for historical inaccuracies. Some of the more egregious historical inaccuracies from his lists are. Jan 26, 2011 in the movie, though, churchill is constantly portrayed as being on georges side. Look up the wikipedia article on any movie based on a real event and youll find a section entitled historical accuracy devoted to tearing apart the work for any liberties taken. He acceded the british throne as king george vi on the abdication of his brother, king edward viii, known as david. As you may have read you will get no hint from the movie that churchill the only british politician of the. Looking back to a time that didnt quite exist the king s speech is an excellent film, but it does take a few pointless liberties with historical accuracy michael white. The kings speech true historical story the daily beast. The king s speech is a 2010 historical drama film directed by tom hooper and written by david seidler. Obviously, the dialogue was composed but the basic facts were largely true. The king s speech is a 2010 film about king george vi of britain, his impromptu ascension to the throne, and the speech therapist who helped the unsure monarch become worthy of it. Stammering in films is usually just for the sake of cruel laughs.
This website shows spotlight accuracy along with other true. The kings speech top 10 historically misleading films. Colin firth plays the future king george vi who, to cope with a stammer, sees lionel logue, an australian speech and language therapist played by geoffrey rush. The kings speech 2010 rotten tomatoes movie trailers. But when george v died and edward became king edward viii, it was not to last. Ithaca, ny the kings speech is a compelling enough story to merit 12 oscar nominations. Her first order of business for kings speech was research. With colin firth playing a royal with a stutter, the kings speech is certain for oscar magic, but andrew roberts says it gets the story all wrong and. Author peter conradi says the relationship between king george. There is a saying that the word is stronger than any other weapon. It features an ensemble cast, led by richard harris as cromwell and alec guinness as king charles i, with. Here is everything you need to know about the true story behind the king and shakespeares telling of that history. How historically accurate is the movie the kings speech.
Hugo vickers, royal adviser on the film the king s speech. With 12 oscar nominations, the king s speech is among the most nominated films of all time. But that doesnt make the kings speech a historically accurate film. Iain canning from seesaw films became involved and, in gareth unwins words. Prince albert, the duke of york, stammers through a speech at the close of the british empire exhibition at wembley stadium. King georges stutter was relatively mild compared to the movie s portrayal. In factchecking the darkest hour, we discovered that while its true that king george vi was not always a fan of churchill, their friendship took much longer to develop in real life. In a critically and commercially disappointing year for the film industry, one of the few highlights has been the reception given to the. We had fiveandahalf weeks to prep for filming the kings speech. A feel good movie in which the king overcomes various personal issues of self worth in a brave feat of public speaking and attempting to overcome his stammer while addressing his people. The kings speech is headed for oscar glory but some have criticized its faulty history. With colin firth playing a royal with a stutter, the kings speech is certain for oscar magic, but andrew roberts says it gets the story all wrong. The king s speech is the story of king george vi colin firth, a.
I will start by saying that the kings speech is an exceptional movie. How historically accurate are the characters and events depicted in the vikings tv show. And when i think of shakespeare, even his history plays, i associate him with that wicked wit. How historically accurate was the kings speech 2010. The story of king george vi, his impromptu ascension to the throne of the british empire in 1936, and the speech therapist who helped the unsure monarch overcome his stammer. Unfortunately, history may have forgotten the courageous and inspiring story of prince albert who stuttered badly and never. New movie releases the king, one of netflixs mostanticipated november releases, follows the life and times of king henry v. The favourite is not a movie thats superconcerned with historical accuracy. Working on a film that tells the story of historical personages.
711 708 1335 109 667 608 481 1098 413 1256 1107 701 518 906 132 37 578 659 761 1297 1425 820 1281 1008 1396 593 282 856 263 450 1505 214 474 231 1043 1159 275 1025 810 1080 233 1120 407 1155 293